Contesting Pluralism(s): Islamism, Liberalism, and Nationalism in Turkey and Beyond

Book Talk by Nora Fisher-Onar

Contesting Pluralism(s) challenges a widespread tendency to limit studies of Turkish – and Muslim – politics to “Islamist vs. secularist” or “Islam vs. democracy” debates. Instead, Nora Fisher-Onar’s innovative argument centres on coalitions for and against pluralism. Retelling Turkey’s story from the late Ottoman Empire to the present as a tale of pluralising vs. anti-pluralist coalitions, this book offers an alternative explanation for major outcomes from elections and coup d’etats to revolutions. Here, cross-camp alliances pit those who are willing to coexist with “Other(s)” against those who champion a unitary, national project in which everyone speaks, believes, looks or loves as they do. Drawing on a rich array of primary and secondary data, Fisher-Onar introduces an analytical framework for capturing causal complexity in political contestation. This study rejects Orientalist exceptionalism, rereading the relationship between political religion, pluralism, and populism via a framework that travels across and beyond the Muslim-majority world.

Nora Fisher-Onar is Associate Professor of International Studies at the University of San Francisco. Her research combines tools from comparative politics, international relations, and area studies to rethink the relationship between religion, politics, and pluralism, challenging Orientalism in how we read Muslim-majority states and societies. Previous publications include Istanbul: Living with Difference in a Global City (2018).